You may have heard some buzz around the upcoming Netflix movie To the Bone , which tells the story of a young woman with anorexia . In the movie, Lily Collins plays Ellen, a sarcastic teenager who struggles with the eating disorder and eventually seeks in-patient treatment despite being unconvinced that she can get better.
The Netflix original debuts on July 14, and its trailers offer a revealing look at the story: Ellen obsessively sticks with her disordered weight-loss methods and is urged by her mother to eat more, often in misguided ways. (In one scene, Ellens mom hands her a cake made to look like a cheeseburger with the words, Eat Up, Ellen! iced on top and laughs about it while her daughter just stares.) Ellen eventually falls under the care of the straight-shooting Dr. William Beckham, played by Keanu Reeves, who attempts to help her and other patients see that recovery is possible.
There's no doubt that anorexia is a difficult, delicate topic for a movie to cover, especially when it's seemingly trying to be funny, heart-wrenching, and bold all at once. So it's no surprise that early reactions to the movie have been mixed, especially among eating disorder experts.
Collins, 27, has been candid about her history with anorexia as a teenager and the fact that she lost weight to play Ellen."It was something that I thought is risky, because theres a fine line between facing something head-on and succeeding, or falling back into it," she told Refinery29 . "But I knew that, this time, I would be held accountable for it. I would be [losing weight] under the supervision of a nutritionist and surrounded by all these amazing women on set. So, I knew that I would be in a safe environment to explore this.
No matter how safe it may seem, some experts allege that it was irresponsible to have someone who has struggled with the condition in the past lose weight for the role, whether under supervision or not.
"Anorexia is a very serious mental illness , and there is the chance that someone can relapse during or after recovery," Heather Senior Monroe, L.C.S.W., director of program development at Newport Academy , tells SELF. "Putting Collins in the position where she needed to lose weight for the role, and essentially relive the disease to an extent, crosses a boundary that is not in alignment with healthy recovery."
Jennifer Carter, Ph.D., a psychologist at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, who specializes in eating disorders and sports, agrees. This aspect of the film is "dangerous," she tells SELF. "Some individuals have risk factors that kick in when they lose weight, and obsessive/addictive [behaviors] can begin."
While it's impossible to be inside Collins' head and know how the weight-loss aspect of the movie affected her, many people with eating disorders will always be in recovery , so the concern is valid.
There's also worry about how Collins' weight loss for the film may impact viewers. Many people with eating disorders think if they dont become extremely thin, then they dont have a real problem, Sarah Altman, Ph.D., a clinical assistant professor in psychiatry and behavioral health at The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, tells SELF.
This couldnt be further from the truth, Dr. Altman says, adding that many patients who have a medically normal weight struggle just as much as those who may fall below the cutoff weight for anorexia. Damaging habits like purging, preoccupation with weight, food rituals, obsession with exercise , and food restriction don't always lead to intense weight loss, but it doesn't mean someone doesn't need help. In that sense, having Collins take on the role without losing weight may have been more responsible and been a teachable moment.
Ellen is a beautiful white teenager whose family can apparently afford to get her top-line treatment. "Eating disorders have historically been associated with young, white women of privilege," says the National Eating Disorders Association . "However, this is a mytheating disorders do not discriminate."
On a related note, some critics point out that the movie may be the latest of many that doesn't address how expensive treatment can beand how, even when someone overcomes stigma around seeking treatment, cost may make it impossible to access the kind of recovery center featured in To the Bone . There may be missed opportunity here to talk about the financial challenges of treatment and the challenge of reaching racial minorities and men, Dr. Altman says.
As she notes, Ellen is treated alongside at least one woman of color and a man, according to the trailer. And it's true that minorities are disproportionally less likely to seek help, according to NEDA, and that the film is set in a recovery clinic. The deliberate narrative choice to center the story of a young white woman whose family can apparently afford treatment still allows the movie to gloss over these important racial and financial conversations.
If the movie skims over these subjects, it can serve to exacerbate stereotypes and leave those who do not fit into any narrow parameters represented feeling [isolated], eating disorder expert Lori Ciotti, L.I.C.S.W., assistant vice president of the Northeast Region of The Renfrew Centers and site director at The Renfrew Center of Boston , tells SELF.
Monroe applauds Netflix and Marti Noxon, the films director, who has a history of anorexia and bulimia , for trying to raise awareness about such an important issue. However, I predict that those suffering with anorexia, or who have suffered from anorexia, will agree that there are points in the film where the disease is unfortunately romanticized and sentimentalized, she says.
Monroe worries that the movie may serve as a trigger for people who are vulnerable. Those who suffer from an eating disorder often strive to reach unhealthy goal weights, and the films main character is someone a vulnerable person could potentially look up to, she explains, adding that the film may inadvertently give people tools to lose weight in an unhealthy way .
In addition to showcasing different methods Ellen uses to lose weight, the trailer is full of graphic images of her thinness. It's possible that the movie could be seen as glorifying the disorder, and possibly motivating for some people who use thinspiration and other forms of social media as a network of support for their behaviors and disorder, Dr. Altman says, explaining that this calls for a warning at the beginning of the movie that informs viewers that what theyre about to see may be triggering.
Any discussion or destigmatizing of eating disorders is something Ciotti is "willing to give a chance. If done well, it can help those suffering feel less isolated and encourage them to reach out for treatment, she says. Collins' and Noxon's personal experience with disordered eating may help translate into a more responsibly told story.
Dr. Altman says that she, too, sees potential pros. She points out that many people think anorexia is just about food, and the movie may help provide insight into the underlying psychological and emotional aspects of the disease.
Dr. Carter says that also its important to highlight the fact that families can struggle with how to help a loved one who has an eating disorder, which the movie seemingly does. Some parents may be in denial for a period of time or blame themselves (even though, Dr. Carter says, there is no evidence that families are often to blame for eating disorders), while others may become more controlling or angry in response to a loved one developing an eating disorder. Eating disorders are not logical and can be so frustrating for the family, Dr. Carter says. Family members often feel helpless.
No doubt everyone involved in To the Bone is aware of this fact. Like anything else, people who have been personally affected by an eating disorder will likely respond to the movie in different ways, Anne Buffington, R.D., C.S.S.D., nutrition program coordinator at Michigan State University who specializes in counseling for people with eating disorders, tells SELF.
"Some may relate to the film and appreciate the voice it can give to this important issue that many are facing, while others may be triggered by what they see depending on where they are at in their own recovery," she says. "Some may be somewhere in between." She advises that anyone who is currently seeking treatment for an eating disorder discuss potential triggers with their treatment team or support system before watching the movie.
Ciotti says she always has concerns that people who are suffering will struggle after seeing something like To the Bone , but that doesnt mean movies on this topic should be avoided altogether. Those who have eating disorders, whether diagnosed or not, can be triggered by so many antecedents on a daily basis, she says. The message of this film seems to be that help is out there.... In my estimation, that should be lauded as an honorable intention.
If you or someone you know is at risk or experiencing an eating disorder, resources are available through NEDA or contact their phone helpline at 1-800-931-2237 or their text crisis line by texting "NEDA" to 741741. You can also visit http://www.eatingrecoverycenter.com to speak to a clinician.
Watch: What Everyone Gets Wrong About Eating Disorders
See the rest here:
Netflix's 'To the Bone' Could Be Harmful to Those With Anorexia - SELF
- To Lose Weight, Cut the Fad Diets and Stick to the Basics, Expert Says - Cornell University The Cornell Daily Sun - December 6th, 2019
- Do these 5 things at every meal to lose weight - New York Post - December 6th, 2019
- The Biggest Loser Revamp is About Being Healthy, Not Losing Weight - Screen Rant - December 6th, 2019
- Weight loss surgery enables a Pinehurst banker to be both half and twice the woman she used to be - Sandhill Sentinel - December 6th, 2019
- Jenna Jameson Says She Gained 20 Lbs. After Taking a Break from Keto to 'Live My Best Carby Life' - PEOPLE Great Ideas - December 6th, 2019
- Rosie Huntington-Whiteley was 'humbled' by struggle to lose baby weight - Page Six - December 6th, 2019
- Not Seeing Results With Keto? This M.D. Says "Sneaky Carbs" May Be To Blame - mindbodygreen.com - December 6th, 2019
- Ajwain water for weight loss: Heres how you should prepare it for better results - Times of India - December 6th, 2019
- How to lose weight and get fit like this 43-year-old Ironman triathlete and open water swimmer - GQ India - What a man's got to do - December 6th, 2019
- From the editor: Finding the best weight management products - NutraIngredients-usa.com - December 6th, 2019
- Boxing: Joshua Lightens the Load as Ruiz Jr Piles on the Pounds - The New York Times - December 6th, 2019
- McDonald's McFlurry Bulldog from Walsall scoops top prize in slimming contest - Birmingham Live - December 6th, 2019
- Eat all daily meals 'within 10 hours' to shed weight - The Times - December 6th, 2019
- Where Does Protein Fit in a New Year Diet? - Technology Networks - December 5th, 2019
- Weight loss: One woman lost a remarkable six stone with this plan - what did she eat? - Express - December 5th, 2019
- 5 Medical Conditions That Cause Weight Loss Without Trying - International Business Times - December 5th, 2019
- 'I Joined Weight Watchers After A Devastating MiscarriageAnd I Found My Joy And Confidence Again' - Women's Health - December 5th, 2019
- Is High-Protein Diet Beneficial For All Of Us? The Answer Will Surprise You - NDTV Food - December 5th, 2019
- Katie Price 'loses a stone in two weeks' and is 'barely eating' over bankruptcy stress - Mirror Online - December 5th, 2019
- Poha for weight loss: The delicious and healthy snack for quick weight loss - Times of India - December 5th, 2019
- Gemma Collins reveals secret to 3st weight loss is storing her food shop in the boot of her car - The Sun - December 5th, 2019
- Weight change between pregnancies is linked to having premature and large at birth babies - Mirage News - December 5th, 2019
- Five Ways To Build Your Innovation Muscles In The New Year - Forbes - December 5th, 2019
- Fitness facilities have the potential to 'be the leading providers of weight loss solutions' - Australasian Leisure Management - December 5th, 2019
- How to lose weight in 6 months like this guy who lost 32 kgs by following an easy cardio routine - GQ India - What a man's got to do - December 5th, 2019
- Eating your last meal at 2pm may help to lose weight 'because it suppresses appetite' - Stock Daily Dish - December 5th, 2019
- Portland in the snow, in a wheelchair - NewsCenterMaine.com WCSH-WLBZ - December 5th, 2019
- Gym routines you should adopt during the festive season - The Standard - December 5th, 2019
- MAFS star Jules on getting married and losing - NEWS.com.au - December 5th, 2019
- Type 2 diabetes: Drinking this type of water could lower blood sugar - Express - December 5th, 2019
- My 600-lb Life: What Happened to Annjeannette Whaley and Vianey & Allen? Where Are They Now? - Earn The Necklace - December 5th, 2019
- Experience: I had apple cider vinegar every morning for 56 days, and this is what happened - Firstpost - December 5th, 2019
- The Christmas Ad That Rode Off With 9% Of Pelotons Share Value - Forbes - December 5th, 2019
- Nutritional fact or fiction? Everything meal replacement companies hope you'll take their word for - Dailyuw - December 2nd, 2019
- Brain receptor that regulates body temperature may also be the key to rapid weight loss - News-Medical.net - December 2nd, 2019
- Best supplements for joints: Taking this supplement could significantly reduce joint pain - Express - December 2nd, 2019
- Weight loss: Six ways to speed up fat loss & the best portion sizes to shed pounds - The Sun - December 2nd, 2019
- Its not hard to eat healthy around the holidays - The Columbus Dispatch - December 2nd, 2019
- Weight loss: This easy plan will help you burn belly fat according to personal trainer - Express - December 2nd, 2019
- 10 ways to tell your partner to lose weight without hurting them - The Nation Newspaper - December 2nd, 2019
- Tips on eating healthy around the holidays - Massillon Independent - December 2nd, 2019
- Want Real Weight Loss? Here Are Three Things You Should Give Up - Medical Daily - December 2nd, 2019
- What Motivated 'Good Morning America's' Tory Johnson To Lose 62 Pounds - Showbiz Cheat Sheet - December 2nd, 2019
- 1st Gen Idol Kim Hyung Jun Of Taesaja Talks About Job As A Delivery Person And His Happiness - soompi - December 2nd, 2019
- How to lose weight like this guy who lost 36 kgs by eliminating these three things from his diet - GQ India - What a man's got to do - December 2nd, 2019
- Protein-Rich Diet: Is It Harmful For People With Kidney Problems? This Study Finds Out - NDTV Food - December 2nd, 2019
- Sizing Up Your Mental Health - Thrive Global - December 2nd, 2019
- Weight loss: I lost 10st after getting so fat I got wedged in a seat on the Tube to work - The Sun - December 2nd, 2019
- This is an interesting way to lose weight in winter - News Track English - December 2nd, 2019
- Younger Women Should Start Now to Defend Against Heart Attacks - catcountry1073.com - December 2nd, 2019
- From Weight-Loss to Wellness: Has The Diet Really Died? - The Bull and Bear - December 2nd, 2019
- To Your Good Health: A flu shot is the best way to prevent the flu - Arizona Daily Star - December 2nd, 2019
- Brush your teeth not twice, but thrice a day: Experts say it may help cut heart failure risk by 12% - Economic Times - December 2nd, 2019
- Weight loss: Top tips to lose weight by improving your digestion - Express - November 28th, 2019
- Aaron Washer Update on My 600 Lb. Life - Heavy.com - November 28th, 2019
- Experts offer tips to avoid gaining that holiday weight - Summit Daily News - November 28th, 2019
- Enjoy the holiday feast; unless you're a wrestler cutting weight - Post Register - November 28th, 2019
- How to lose weight & build muscles like this guy who followed an easy yet quantifiable regime to get ripped - GQ India - What a man's got to do - November 28th, 2019
- An Increasing Number of Americans Weigh 200 Poundsand Say They Are OK With It - Newsweek - November 28th, 2019
- Holly Willoughby weight loss: How did the daytime TV star trim down? - Express.co.uk - November 28th, 2019
- Waitress loses 125lbs to fulfil her grandfather's dying wish - Somerset Live - November 28th, 2019
- Losing almost 12 stone cured my diabetes... and saved my life - The Sunday Post - November 28th, 2019
- Alfred Dawes | Severe obesity: The harsh truth | Health - Jamaica Gleaner - November 28th, 2019
- Technology Advances in Reducing Lower Back Pain - HealthTechZone - November 28th, 2019
- Bored of the gym? Try these martial art forms for weight loss and muscle tone - Firstpost - November 28th, 2019
- 'My daughter's death took me to the darkest place, but I've learned it's possible to come back' - Telegraph.co.uk - November 28th, 2019
- 'Creative, intelligent and cheeky': Mother blames son's death on drug access in Richmond - 9News - November 28th, 2019
- Insta Keto Report (Instant Keto): Important News Reported By Researched Reviews - The Prowess News - November 28th, 2019
- Embracing the weight of discomfort, Entertainment News & Top Stories - The Straits Times - November 28th, 2019
- Ask the GP: Menopause may be causing your infuriating itch - The Irish News - November 28th, 2019
- Weight loss: This guy lost a massive 50 kilos in less than 8 months! Here's how he did it - Times of India - November 27th, 2019
- If You Want to Lose Weight and Keep It Off, This is the Magic Number of Calories to Cut Every Day - LIVESTRONG.COM - November 27th, 2019
- Lose Weight and Be Healthy with the 10-Day Metagenics Detox Diet - University Herald - November 27th, 2019
- Severe obesity: The harsh truth | Health - Jamaica Gleaner - November 27th, 2019
- How one UAE-based woman lost almost 50kg in a year - Gulf News - November 27th, 2019
- Hoda Kotb and Jenna Bush Hager Say They Didnt Think Through Their Live Weigh-In: It Was a Shock - PEOPLE.com - November 27th, 2019
- The Benefits of Red Wine for Health, Skin and Weight Loss - Femina - November 27th, 2019
- Five natural appetite suppressants for weight loss that actually work - Times of India - November 27th, 2019
- Al Roker Reveals What Used To Cause Him to Overeat and Why He's 'Never Going Back to Fat' - Showbiz Cheat Sheet - November 27th, 2019
- Weight loss: Top 5 health benefits of Muay Thai - Times of India - November 27th, 2019